Kajko, Weisman & Colasanti, LLP

More courts beginning to declare DOMA violates the Constitution

In our last post, we discussed the potential for federal laws like the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) to play a role in Massachusetts divorce proceedings. That law has been at the forefront of the debate regarding same-sex marriages and divorces. Recent federal court rulings are challenging the validity of the law, declaring it to be unconstitutional.

In a case from the Ninth Circuit, a District Court Judge ruled that DOMA contravened a homosexual woman's Fifth Amendment rights to equal protection under the law. The court was not the first to find that DOMA violated a person's constitutional rights. The court did distinguish itself, however, in how it examined DOMA under the Constitution.

In constitutional cases, judges apply varying levels of scrutiny to laws depending on certain criteria. The least demanding level of scrutiny is called rational basis. Few laws examined under rational basis are declared unconstitutional. But the court applied a rational basis review to DOMA and determined that the law failed to pass that lenient standard. In his written opinion, the judge stated, "gay men and lesbians are a group deserving of heightened protection against the prejudices and power of an often-antagonistic majority." A separate case from the First Circuit also deemed DOMA unconstitutional using a rational basis level of scrutiny.

In time, cases like these may come to profoundly reshape the federal laws that have a bearing on same-sex marriages and divorces. It will be important to follow their progress through the legal system and examine what changes they may create.

Source: The Recorder, "San Francisco Judge Finds DOMA Unconstitutional," Ginny LaRoe, Feb. 22, 2012.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For a Response

Tell Us About Your Case

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Lexington Office
430 Bedford Street, Suite 390
Lexington, MA 02420

Phone: 978-296-5107
Fax: 781-861-1833
Lexington Law Office Map

Nashua Office
98 Spit Brook Road
Suite 1105
Nashua, NH 03062

Phone: 781-325-1786
Fax: 603-324-5101
Map & Directions

Andover Office
68 Main Street, Suite 4
Andover, MA 01810

Phone: 781-325-1786
Map & Directions